General Balancing Thread

I wanted to create a thread on the forums since I notice balancing thoughts on Discord oftentimes get brought up, spur some conversation, and get forgotten. This is a thread for ideas which don’t require their own forums - an entire rework to the difficulty system for example should deserve a thread of its own. This is more meant to call discussion to a specific area, or store thoughts.

————

Storage

To start, I wanted to discuss storage balancing. Currently, I personally almost never find the need to use a vacuole, and very rarely see players create organisms with a vacuole in it on the showcase section of Discord (I saw maybe 2 creatures with them skimming it).

I definitely don’t think that vacuoles have to be a standard for every single cell, but I do think this points to storage being an exceedingly abundant resource for organisms. There are rarely times where I think “man, I wish I had more storage”. And it shouldn’t be so that my organism is constantly starved of resources, but players should be forced to consider means of increasing storage capacities; it creates deeper and more intentional thought towards fleshing out your organism.

I want to try two things:

  1. Reduce storage amounts for all parts and see how that goes
  2. Reduce storage amounts for eukaryotic parts only since storage for prokaryotes is less approachable

I think a fundamental part of this issue is the fact that storage starts getting doubled as your organs split for reproduction, which I do honestly think is problematic for balancing purposes as a whole. It makes it so that you have to treat values as double, which can make balancing for a single part excessive, and balancing for two parts punishing during the players time as the organism they actually created.

That’s a more dedicated revamp though, so I will be trying to json some storage.

2 Likes

Any luck with this? Obviously I could made that branch for you if you need me to, but it sounded like you got this.

3 Likes

Thanks for the check in! No need for the branch, but if this is something you personally want to see addressed soon and I’m being slow, I won’t be upset if you go for it. I’m going to try to attempt some balancing either this week or the next.

1 Like