Macroscopic Core Gameplay Discussion

[I thought I saw a thread that Rathalos created similar to this, but I couldn’t find it anywhere. If there is a thread like this, I can delete this one and just reply to the original one to keep discussions organized].


We are very close to the Macroscopic Stage, the quintessential “Belgium hits the fan” phase of the game when it comes to our scope. Discussion has been occurring about specific aspects of the Macroscopic - the transition from micro-to-macro, or the editor - but actual gameplay discussion is spread throughout those threads.

So having a thread focused primarily on gameplay itself would be useful. It’s a pretty broad topic, but if specific themes keep emerging, we can create separate threads for those too.

I will begin discussion by focusing on the gameplay loop, and proposing some sort of “evaluation” criteria for gameplay.

The Gameplay Loop

I don’t think this will end up being very different from what it is now at a fundamental level - spawn in, show your design is adapted enough to this environment to successfully reproduce, tweak your design, repeat. But I do think that the game transitioning from an abstract representation of a world to a fully 3D, geographically distinct environment brings some changes we have to be mindful of.

Two things stick out in my mind:

  • The gameplay loop will likely have to be longer so that players can fully experience what this stage can offer.
  • Because geography is more explicitly simulated, the world itself could very dramatically change in a few generations.

The first point is pretty straightforward, but the second point deserves some more reflection. In the microscopic phase of Thrive, you spawn into a background, reproduce/evolve, then spawn back into that same background with relatively little difference in the environment. But in the Macroscopic/Aware Stages, you spawn into an environment, reproduce/evolve, and can very well spawn into a completely new environment. A jungle can turn into a plain, a continental shelf can turn into a shallow sea, etc.

This is very interesting, but also can shorten some of the impact and gameplay narratives that our procedural planet can offer. For both “pure” gameplay purposes - having some measure of consistency, not completely surprising the player with a dramatically new world, the player truly proving themselves well-adapted to their current world - and more “abstract” gameplay purposes - the player’s understanding of the world, their emotional connection to a specific place as it transforms, the narratives forming in the player’s story - we need to both represent the timespans involved in evolution, and allow players to soak in their current world if they so choose.

If the way we represent the world is too stable and consistent, then we risk degrading the feeling of the world changing through the millions of years a player follows their species. In Earth’s history, this would be like assuming the world of the Cambrian, Carboniferous, Cretaceous, and Paleocene are incredibly similar - when in reality, so many moments of our planet’s history would look completely alien.

If the way we represent the world is too transient and inconsistent, then we risk degrading the identities and connection a player feels with their world. In Earth’s history, this would eliminate the narrative of, say, Australia’s unique lifeforms having a uniquely Australian identity, or the local stories of a forgotten Antarctican jungle. Balance is urgent.


Control Levers for Balancing Change vs. Stability

So, what are some control levers we have here? And by control levers, I mean things we can do to help moderate this design question. What mechanics and progression elements will be present to help us balance both the change and the consistency we need to represent?

I think there are two big “tools” we can use:

  • Pacing of Environmental Change - Exactly how we pace the way the world changes, and how frequently it does.

  • Player-Pace Progression Mechanics - Gameplay loops are somewhat flexible and not very set, and player has broad discretion over when they choose to end a specific loop.

Pacing of Environmental Change

Many games which represent events over a great period of time - Civilization and other 4X games, EU4/5 and other strategy games - tend to represent significant change in a somewhat controlled manner. Certain events and effects occur for a specific amount of time, the player somewhat understands what these events and effects entail, and is generally aware of how long a specific phase of the game will last.

We can introduce similar pacing mechanics to Thrive if we think it is appropriate. For example, when it comes to tectonic plates - larger changes can only occur every X number of generations, while smaller changes are more dynamic.

Player-Paced Progression

I’m going to commit a no-no here - let’s think of Spore’s Creature Stage (audience gasps).

In Spore, you can enter and exit the editor whenever you want to. You can enter the editor as soon as you exit it by pressing backspace - similarly, you can enter the editor an hour after you first spawn. The game encourages you to continue experiencing the world you live in by tying progression to exploration, as you both unlock editor points and parts through interacting with other organisms and sites in Spore.

Spore’s world will not change as much as Thrive’s, and will not be as dynamic: but the takeaway here is that the player determines how quickly they progress throughout the stage. And I think that would be a very valuable progression style to model in Thrive.

I still think we should have some sort of minimal period a player needs to survive in Thrive, as it is fundamental to the whole “prove your organism can survive” idea. But if we want to introduce aspects of a player-paced progression loop into Thrive, we would need to introduce mechanics that reward the player for playing in their current world for longer.


Evaluation Criteria

Another thing I will drop for consideration here. Given that this is probably Thrive’s most unique stage, we need to make sure that it is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, fun. A good way to pursue a goal is to define smaller goals.

The below are categories of what goals and questions we can ask ourselves in designing concepts. Goals for each “aspect” of fun are listed, as well as an example sentence of this goal working well.

I think if we develop each category more into smaller objectives/questions and then have answers for those questions, we can go a pretty long way in having a very robust core gameplay loop.

Engagement - Is the actual gameplay action itself fun?

  • Goal: Getting food, movement, and interacting with the world is actually fun.

  • “Who knew that scrapping moss off a rock can be so satisfying? Next time I get to the editor, I want to see if I can scrape off even more moss in one go.”

Motivation - Does the player desire to accomplish a goal?

  • Goal: Players desire to achieve an overarching goal, and are able to set their own goals.

  • “This time, I’m going to try and create the fastest running organism possible. This will be a good challenge, since I need to make sure I can grab tools if I want to go forward.”

Pacing - Does the player feel neither stuck or rushed?

  • Goal: Players feel that they are moving towards something, but are able to pace how quickly they move towards that something.

  • “I really enjoy being this slug thing. Let me try and see if I can continue with this body plan for 5 more generations, then I’ll probably need to pivot.”

Gameplay Transformation - Do different approaches genuinely change gameplay rather than stats?

  • Goal: Gameplay across different saves provides similar core mechanics, but the way the player interacts with the world can differ dramatically.

  • “Now that I grew from 5 feet to 30 feet long, I am much less nimble and require much more food. I can’t continue to eat the same things I did - I need to pivot into a new niche.”

Communication - Does the player understand what’s going on, and how to do things?

  • Goal: Players aren’t overwhelmed or given answers, but understand what they are doing well, and where they can improve.

  • “I see that my organism has a very high population right now, but I notice that the weather is getting cold. I see that I should get thicker skin and less surface area to tolerate the cold more, so I’ll do that.”

Challenge & Mastery - Is the player sufficiently challenged, while having enough room to experiment?

  • Goal: Gameplay requires the player to be resourceful, but not every setback means the game is over; players have a chance to try again without losing hours of progress.

  • “My attempt to sustain myself fully on shelled organisms failed. Let me try and pivot into eating soft-bodied organisms”.

7 Likes

The environmental changes are definitely going to be a tough thing to make fun, but they’re also really important. I think a big problem we need to solve is that surviving a changing environment largely requires a species to be lucky instead of good. The species that survive mass extinction events aren’t the “best” species, they’re the species that are lucky enough to be less affected by the changes than everything else.

A player could play around that by making a really general species that’s specifically designed to survive in a wide range of environments so they’re more likely to survive a rapidly changing environment, but I think that’s less fun than making a specialized species that dominates their niche in a specific environment.

Something like this could help with that. For example, the player can be warned that a global cooling event will start in 3 generations, so they have time to try to adapt (higher difficulties would probably give less warning).

I’m not sure how well this would translate to Thrive, at least in regard to environmental changes. The player should be allowed to play a single generation for as long as they want, but each generation would still need to represent a certain number of years, right? Which means the environment would still change the same amount, regardless of what the player does.

Although, letting the player goof off in the jungle for an hour before everything dies from a volcanic eruption might at least make them a little less sad.

All of the criteria you listed seem important to me, but I think this criterion in particular is huge and I’d also consider it one of Thrive’s strengths in the current stages. When I first played, I was surprised at how different the game felt depending on your primary source of energy.

In my opinion, this criterion also most clearly symbolizes the point of a multi-stage evolution simulator. The choices you make should have real gameplay impacts for potentially the entirety of the game, all the way through the space stage.

3 Likes

these are smaller features inside the macro stage that i would like to see, as they make for interesting little fun facts: I think in the macro stage, instead of 50 MY it should be 10 MY per editor, since life is advancing way faster after reaching the macro stage from what i know (i may be wrong). Also, a little and fun fun fact about the player’s creature in macro could be the amount of cells it is made out of (this will have no gameplay impact whatsoever, and it will be calculated from the size, amount of organs and body parts). this would make some people think of their creature as a more advanced species rather than just a blob of body parts.

Oh, I was actually still writing it. Though I don’t think there’s actually much overlap with what you have here, since while you’re focused here on the highest-level concept, I’ve been writing more on the moment-to-moment gameplay interactions with the movement system, food sources, metabolism, etc. Not in the highest possible detail, but still quite detailed.

Kind of wondering if I should post it here or split those topics into their own posts. But I think you’ve given me some good criteria to keep in mind for those topics.

What this specifically does remind me of is the different geologic era that you mentioned before. Perhaps we can design it so that there are indeed climatic periods that are stable for multiple generations before changing quite suddenly, which would then be accompanied by mass extinctions and change of the biome.

I’m wondering if we can offer the player to “reproduce without entering the editor.” Basically using that to boost your population number as a reward for playing more in an era.

From what I’ve seen it’s indeed usually small generalists that do the best. I’m hoping that the player’s innate ability to push through in gameplay ins situations where they might not be the most optimal species design, in combination with the ability to make edits when disaster hits, would be enough for them to survive.

I think pretty much everyone agrees on this.

2 Likes

I think here we should keep in mind that the intended/planned thing to happen when the player species dies in normal (not hardcore) mode is that the player switches over to the most closely related surviving species. In my view this should be something that happens semi-regularly in most playthroughs in which the player chooses fun/experimentation/roleplay over optimization.

If we view earth as a playthrough in which humans eventually arw the player species which reached sapience, that shouldn‘t mean that the player only ever played it safe up until very recently in evolutionary history by staying small survivalist omnivores. They could have branched off into any number of somewhat closely related species which became apex predators or something more exiting along the way, with mass extinctions kind of „setting them back“ to a related but less specialized/more adaptable species.

Crusader Kings is a great parallel/example here. The core gameplay loop inherently involves your character dying and you taking control of your heir, who might be a child, might have a serious disability and/or might only inherit part of your titles. Nevertheless, you eventually stack certain advantages like artefacts, dynasty legacies and costumarily good relations with other dynasties which will eventually help you overcome these odds and make successive setbacks easier and quicker to overcome.

In the style of the imagined player quotes with which @Deus came up in the original post and which I find very helpful:

„Nooo, I was just this Disturbance-like apex predator and now that the meteor hit a few generations ago and it became very cold my species became extinct after about three generations of cold climate and dwindling prey populations. I should have pivoted to q scavanging lifestyle right away after the meteor impact… Now I‘m playing as this lizard-sized insectivore which split off my lineage 20 generations ago. But I can still recognize it as a close relative by its otherwise Disturbance-like body plan which I designed 30 generations ago like the large singular ear-like face and the six limbs. Let‘s see if I can rebound and reach Awakening Stage before the next meteor hits, then I might be able to survive the cold by utilizing tools such as fire or clothing…“

In Crusader Kings gameplay loop, the equivalent of reaching sapience is basically getting enough titles for forming an empire which makes your gains more stable before losing them again due to inheritance splitting or due to losing them in wars/coups etc.

So I regard player species extiction more as a punishing but also exitingly challenging part of the regular gameplay loop. Does this make sense?

2 Likes

I think it’s a valid option. But this would be a change, as currently in normal mode, “Allow switching to related species on extinction” is disabled.

What I was referring to before is that I think the first priority should be that the underlined is possible. Being able to switch species is a backup.

3 Likes

As far as I‘m aware, environmental events in microbe stage as they are currently implemented are rather tame compared to the mass extinctions being discussed here for the 3D stages. And this probably should/will stay that way for the foreseeable future since the simulated environment of the microscopic/2D stages is extremely simplified anyway compared to what will come in the macroscopic stages.

The player species going extinct semi-regularly seems less sensible for the 2D stages anyways for multiple other reasons. Firstly, the distinction between generalist/opportunistic survival optimized species and more specialized species seems less clear at this scale since all of them are quiet tiny and simple anyways compared to the macroscopic species. Secondly, the 2D species are quiet hard to tell apart anyways and all look rather samey compred to more recognizable macroscopic organisms (this isn‘t a cricism of how microbes and multicellulars are portrayed in the game, it just reflects the reality that species are more recognizable to us humans when they‘re macroscopic. So dying and taking over another species might feel much more jarring in the 2D stages since there is no general body plan thay you designed that you might recognize in your fall-back species.

But the question is then, if this mechanic were to change between 2D and 3D, is this a strange and arbitrary-feeling switch? And how would it be communicated to the player?

In my opinion, the large extinction events are not only very crucial parts of real evolutionary history, but they also offer the potential for exiting gameplay challenges and variety. It would be a huge missed opportunity to water them down just because it might initially feel strange or frustrating to some players to be set back like that.

1 Like

This is the thing that concerns me most about realistic mass extinctions in Thrive, we don’t want extinctions to be thought of as just making the world more boring, taking out the most interesting and well adapted organisms and instead only allowing boring organisms to survive. Isn’t the popular perception of the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event that it just made everything more boring immediately afterwards? It could make sense for Hard mode, but I don’t think it is the expectation that players would have for Easy mode.

This seems like a very good point to bring up, as I have been assuming that this is not how things are intended to be.

I think that is the main problem with making player extinction expected, it would be inherently frustrating. That is not to say that I think it would be impossible to make it a fun feature, its just that it seems far more difficult to do and would default to frustrating, not fun. You bring up Crusader Kings as a good example of it being well done, which I agree with. But I am not sure how well it would work for Thrive. We don’t want our gameplay to be static, but neither do we want it to be fully transient, as Deus has layed out so well in the first post. I think that the player extinction as default could easily end up making the player feel disconnected and disinvested from their organism if you are forced to switch as an expected part of the game.

This seems like a good time to really figure out if we want to go this way, as it seems like the momentum is already against it as the first two stages already set up the expectation that extinction is a complete loss.

4 Likes

I do think part of that will represent a balancing act between specialization and being more of a generalist. Ideally, specialization gives you dominance over a specific niche/playstyle, but ties your fate more strongly to whatever it is you are specialized in. Generalization gives you some resilience, but often requires more “expensive” adaptations and has the risk of being outcompeted in various parts of your strategy.

I am a bit less strict on the whole “a certain amount of time must pass in between each editor trip” conversation - if we take this too literarily, than basically every extinction event in Earth’s history would be skipped over if we have a 10 MY time-jump (it took around 10 MY for biodiversity to recover from the Permian Extinction, for example). So in interest of representing these events, we would either need to reduce the amount of time passed during environmental events, or generally accept that Thrivian environmental events stretch out for much longer.

Though I will say that I don’t think climate change should occur within a player’s lifetime (barring seasons, or very specific events if we are able to represent) - the world the player spawns into should generally stay consistent for as long as they play it, and change upon entering the editor in my opinion. Unless I misunderstood what you were saying.

Agree here. I would think some level of dynamism here would be cool here - some editor trips might be 10 MY, others might be 5 MY, etc. I previously thought it would be cool to attach that to the amount of MP spent in an editor trip, but that doesn’t account for quick radiations or living fossils.

Another option is to have the amount of years passing slow down in climate events since evolution tends to happen quickly there. So if the planet experienced a meteor collapse, the next few editor jumps will represent 500,000 years instead of 10 MY. Not essential, but nice for flavoring.

I’d agree that these should be their own topic - it would be great to focus on the core gameplay actions, ensuring they are fun, intuitive, and dynamic. If we play our cards right, just the act of moving or eating could be interesting and engaging.

I am starting to convince myself that would be an ideal way to organize distinct phases of the game - have some baseline that is stable throughout an era, and then dramatically change that baseline through a traumatic event, inducing a new baseline. There would of course be changes throughout each era - patches can still change due to vegetation levels, some temperature and geological changes - but these events will represent significant, changes. The Mesozoic had a lot of climate variety because of its timespan, but it was generally much warmer than our current world, and more moist than the Permian which preceded it.

I think what would be useful is to separate what volatility we think is appropriate just as a continuous part of change throughout the game, and what aspect of the game should be volatile and expressed through these era changes.

This could be an important benefit if we make extinction events genuinely difficult. I feel like there’s some other interesting bonus we can provide as well, but nothing is coming to mind as of now.

Leaving this here: How Difficult Should Thrive Be? - #5 by Deus

But the basic gist of that conversation is the idea that species switching should be a more significant part of the gameplay loop, perhaps through a “lives” mechanic that gives you a limited number of chances to switch to maintain challenge. So you’d start off with 2 switches (lives) in the Microbe Stage, gain a life every time you progress to a different stage, and lose only if you run out of switches. Rathalos had an interpretation of not limiting this switching at all, and just allowing players to switch upon every extinction.

A really fun part about many sandbox games, like KSP or Crusader Kings, is seeing everything blow up and trying again after. The issue with Thrive is that if everything blows up, you’re done. Not only does this limit player creativity, but it also limits the problems we ask the player to solve - if extinction means the entire game ends, then we can’t ever really throw a challenge that is immensely difficult for the player to work through. So our conversation of making environment/extinction events really difficult would not fly at all.

Beyond just gameplay and realism - a playthrough in Thrive is going to be really long. I can’t imagine playing through a 6 hour playthrough, reaching the macroscopic stage, and losing all those 6 hours because you made one wrong decision and entered a death loop. The two potential solutions would be to make sure that players can recover from anything by making events much less scary, or to give them chances to try and solve a difficult problem again. And I’d much prefer the latter.

That was my main issue with just having the “switch upon extinction” feature be enabled for everything, and the idea behind having some sort of “lives” feature attached to extinction and switching. Going back to my favorite (desired) analogue for Thrive, KSP - you crash a lot, but in the career mode, you have limited amount of funds/resources/whatever so that you aren’t just willing to throw rockets against the wall. You may have a safety net, but you genuinely do need something to work eventually.

That way - you have margin of safety for experimentation and for trying out new things, but you do need to succeed eventually. You have a lose condition to be mindful of.


Linking this as well since it’s been mentioned as context a few times this conversation: Changing Role of the Environment in the Macroscopic Stages

3 Likes

I guess it is fair to design for the desired end state at the start. I mention this because various world terrain etc. changes might be really hard to get programmed in. So designs that rely on this to make sense, might not make sense until very late into macroscopic development (or even might get skipped if it’s the only thing left and we can’t make progress on it).

Why does this sound like the opposite of what the new option for resetting world each time upon exiting the editor would do?

We’ve kind of already did this with the glaciation event which lasts much longer in Thrive than in reality to have some coherence with subsequent microbe generations.

I think this is achieved in the microbe stage already. We have the idealized number of generations it takes to pass the stage, but from somewhat recent polling it seems the average player (or at least Discord fan) plays the stage for double the number of generations. So there is already Thrive players taking their time and other players can speedrun a stage if they want to taking vastly less time. I think the same design would work in macroscopic.

cough glaciation event in microbe stage cough

If we follow the conventions set out by the microbe stage, then the player species going extinct would be a thing that shouldn’t happen on normal difficulty even if the player needs to experiment a bit to find a viable strategy.

Breaking that design in macroscopic would be a bit unfortunate, because we taught the player that in the microbe stage. We even have a tutorial telling the player to load an earlier save if they made mistakes.

So we teach the player in the microbe stage to not go extinct. Thus, I do not think it is a good design that we would expect the player to go extinct in macroscopic just because the player hasn’t been prepared for that in the earlier game. I think macroscopic should be a learning continuation from the microbe stage rather than needing to unlearn mechanics taught by the earlier stage.

I would say that it is too arbitrary for a single game to pivot so hard.

Rather than designing from scratch, I think we should design things to be a continuation of the microbe stage. And thus, once again I remind people of the existence of the global glaciation event in the microbe stage, which I think should be the starting point of discussing how similar events would work and be presented to the player in the macroscopic and further stages.

2 Likes

I agree. I love these small yet noticeable features since they make the game feel more alive rather than just a mechanical “10 MY passed”

I would love to see mega-hard Extinction events, as right now only the global glaciation event poses a mildly inconvenient threat. maybe have it as an option to enable genuinely hard and dreadful extinction events so that casual players can enjoy more peaceful Thrive and challengers like me can enjoy a bit of a challenge. also the reproducing without an editor seems like a great idea, sometimes i just don’t want to change anything and is forced to click 3 buttons to get out of the editor.

i don’t know what hhyyrylainen was trying to say, but i disagree with the warnings.

Extinction events are supposed to be unexpected, pushing you to rapidly evolve and adapt to them.

Hence me wanting harder extinction events

What if instead of “lives” letting you switch species, they just let you enter the editor again after you die?

Right now, having a more populous species in the Microbe stage already gives you extra lives when your organism dies, so we could keep that same idea here instead of giving them a preset number of lives. That way, if the player is completely dominating before the mass extinction event, they’ll have more chances to evolve before becoming extinct.

We probably wouldn’t want to base it strictly off population because that favors smaller organisms, but we could come up with some kind of metric to gauge how “dominant” a species is, like maybe the percentage of the world’s energy they consume.

This would be less realistic than making them swap species, but I think it would feel drastically more rewarding for the player.

Edit: Or, if we don’t think it makes sense to give them lives based on some metric, we could keep Deus’ original idea of giving them a preset number of lives, but still let them use those lives to enter the editor with their current species when they die instead of those lives letting them switch species when they become extinct.

1 Like

I have to say that I cannot accept such things for normal Thrive difficulty.

I have joked in the past that for people wanting harder extinction events we could add a message that has like 10% chance to show up and just says “A meteor hit your planet wiping out all life, game over”

I just cannot see such a thing as good game design.

There’s a tutorial already in the game telling the player to load their last editor auto save if they die too many times in a row.

Even if we switch the macroscopic stage to use a number of lives instead of population, we can just represent that through the population number by tuning by how much it lowers each death we can effectively implement a fixed or slightly variable number of lives. And this would work without the player realizing that we have changed the mechanics of dying.

1 Like

i don’t want these 100% of life died, i mean i want an harder extinction event for example that makes it significantly harder to survive (buildup of poisonous gas, affecting osmeregulation, etc.)

Couldn‘t have put it better!

Fair, I suppose that would be bad game design.

My conclusion from these two arguments is that we should adopt the following design philosphy in this regard (quoted from another thread):

Right now, the „hardcore mode“ without species switching might be the default mode, but environmental events are quiet tame, and if we also want player extinction to be a game over state which will result in the player having to reload an old file in the later stages, they will also have to be relatively tame in the later stages compared to irl.

Other players, who favour a KSP or Crusader Kings hardcore mode (where you can’t reload saves, but you can still inherit upon death as this is part of the core gameplay) gameplay style might enable switching species upon extinction (maybe also with a sort of lives count or relatedness limit) but crank the event severeness all the way up. This way, the game can be experienced in these different ways. Environmental event severeness, species switching upon extinction and save reloadability seem like the most central ways of costumizing this gameplay style/difficulty.

I’m pretty sure it has been discussed in the past that we have very limited resources, so doing multiple major variants of a game’s stage is not the most viable idea. Especially if we need to make major new features for a harder difficulty mode with more game mechanics.

3 Likes

This isn‘t really about adding new mechanics the way I see it. It‘s rather about implementing a single mechanic (like mass extincions based on meteor impacts etc) and then changing the numbers so they are more or less severe depending on settings.

Well yeah, that wouldn’t be hard to tweak specifically, but there was discussion in this thread about having more advanced simulation features / more in-depth systems the player has to use to survive in macroscopic. Those would be the really high effort stuff to do that most players would never see as they wouldn’t play on hard mode.

1 Like

I would just like to re-emphasize that “player survives disaster and continues the playthrough” is a product of “severity of problem” and “tools player has to overcome the problem.” You can throw a severe problem at the player, because they do have a lot of ways to fix it.

If you do throw a problem at the player that is so severe that it cannot be solved with tools available, that’s not a difficult challenge, that’s just an arbitrary loss. That causes frustration, and being able to switch to a related species doesn’t do much to resolve that, because the player did not actually do anything to allow that to happen. (In fact, the difference between the player species and the other species that allowed the latter species is specifically what the player did not do) It’s still going to be seen as just a loss state.

I think what’s being overlooked here is the more “classic” game experience that, as hhyyrylainen alluded to, the game already encourages:

  1. You enter the editor and see that a drastic change has occurred.
  2. You see that your species, as it is, will not do well. This is the challenge presented.
  3. You use the tools within the editor as best as you can to overcome this challenge, and exit the editor.
  4. The situation in-gameplay is also still difficult. This is the other half of the challenge, with the other half of the tools. You try your best to survive and reproduce with the tools available.
  5. You die, and return to point 4, that’s a minor failure.
  6. You go extinct, or realise on your own terms that you won’t be able to win. You reload your previous save and so go back to point 3 and try an entirely different approach.

Until you eventually succeed. That’s not a bad gameplay loop in my opinion, and similar ones have worked in countless video games over the decades.

I don’t think the CK and KSP comparisons entirely fly for different reasons:

  • For CK, the position of your dynasty in different places to a large degree is because you yourself have put them in positions of power. So you did have a large degree of influence over the possibilities available to you. In Thrive, this is much more limited.
  • For KSP, to be honest the most common response I see to complete failures is returning to a previous state and retrying. Either a specific manoeuvre, or returning to the build and making adjustments. Which is exactly the loop I describe above. And even if you do just accept failure of a mission and start another build, the consequences are not at all comparable to losing your current species design and having to pick a different one within the same world.

So, to summarize: equating “extinction events should be severe” with “the player needs to potentially be in an unfixable situation, and thus needs to be able to pick another species” is I believe entirely the wrong way to be looking at this design question. (Edited to add: Because, being faced with an unavoidable extinction because you didn’t do something different several generations ago just isn’t fun regardless, especially with random unpredictable events)

Making events like global glaciation more significant is also possible without giving players no-win situations I believe, because it’s currently pretty ignorable.


If we do want to switch to a game design where (by default) situations may be unfixable and switching to related species is a core part of the experience, that would need be reworked in Microbe and Multicellular as well.

I agree that such things should not change so significantly between Stages of the game.

4 Likes

I fully agree with you. I just wanted to point out one piece of feedback I have heard a few times related to the events:

Unless you are a plant and a new-ish player. From those people I have seen a few comments that glaciation “ruined their game”. So I assume there are some skill levels and gameplay scenarios where glaciation is much harder than it usually seems to most people.

2 Likes